On Sunday, The Harvard Crimson printed an opinion piece by an nameless member of the Harvard Faculty Honor Council who votes on plagiarism circumstances.
The piece addresses Homosexual’s “numerous and serious violations of academic ethics” and requires her resignation.
Along with the plagiarism accusations, it is usually alleged that Gay refused to share her analysis with two professors who questioned a knowledge technique she utilized in a 2001 Stanford paper they are saying “usually resulted in ‘logical inconsistencies.’”
Winkfield Twyman Jr., a former regulation college professor and Harvard graduate, has additionally accused Homosexual of making a career out of “disrupting” black male scholars.
Within the Crimson opinion piece, the author compares the therapy of Harvard undergraduates suspected of plagiarism with that of Homosexual, saying that within the 2021-22 college 12 months, the final 12 months for which information is publicly obtainable, 43 percent of cases involved plagiarism or misuse of sources.
The author notes that, in accordance with Harvard’s personal definitions, omitting citation marks, citing sources incompletely, or not citing sources in any respect constitutes plagiarism.
In my expertise, when college students omit citation marks and citations, as President Homosexual did, the sanction is normally one time period of probation — a everlasting mark on a pupil’s document. A pupil on probation is now not thought-about in good standing, disqualifying them from alternatives like fellowships and study-abroad packages. Good standing can be required to obtain a level.
What’s hanging in regards to the allegations of plagiarism towards President Homosexual is that the improprieties are routine and pervasive.
She is accused of plagiarism in her dissertation and at the very least two of her 11 journal articles. Two sentences from the acknowledgment part of her dissertation even appear to have been copied from one other work.
********
When my friends are discovered answerable for a number of situations of insufficient quotation, they’re usually suspended for an instructional 12 months. When the president of their college is discovered accountable for a similar kinds of infractions, the fellows of the Company “unanimously stand in help of” her.
There may be one customary for me and my friends and one other, a lot decrease customary for our College’s president. The Company ought to resolve the double customary by demanding her resignation.
The opinion piece concludes with a telling editor’s word that gives a glimpse of the environment on the college and the protecting bubble positioned round Homosexual, “Editor’s Observe: To be able to shield the writer from retaliation, and since the proceedings of the Harvard Faculty Honor Council are delicate and confidential, we made the choice to grant this writer anonymity.”