Medan, Indonesia – In response to native ranger Ajo, nobody ought to have been trekking on Mount Marapi, certainly one of Indonesia’s most well-known volcanoes situated in West Sumatra, on December 3, 2023.
For nearly a 12 months, the 25-year-old information, who had led excursions on the mountain from 2020 to 2022, had been warning authorities in regards to the elevated volcanic exercise on the peak, and his fears that climbers would die if the energetic volcano erupted.
Sadly, his prediction in regards to the volatility of Mount Marapi proved to be right.
About 75 hikers have been on the mountain when it erupted earlier this month, sending a 2,000-foot-high (600-metre) ash plume into the sky.
No less than 24 folks have been killed, the vast majority of them succumbing to critical burns.
When Ajo heard in regards to the catastrophe, he was horrified as a result of he had at all times thought of the security of his company to be paramount, he mentioned.
“I additionally at all times educated company about fundamental emergency mitigation procedures. If my company needed to go to the height of the volcano, I might educate them first and take note of the climate. If it was not attainable, then I wouldn’t enable them to go near the height,” Ajo instructed Al Jazeera.
Ajo, who’s from West Sumatra, mentioned that he was strict about different security measures, insisting that company solely climb close to the crater at daybreak and depart by 11am to keep away from spending too lengthy near the “hazard zone”.
He additionally used different native information to maintain company secure, reminiscent of solely establishing camp in areas of thick vegetation, as an alternative of rocky areas uncovered to the weather, and the place earlier eruptions had already scorched the land.
However regardless of loving his job escorting hikers to certainly one of Indonesia’s most lovely peaks, Ajo stopped engaged on the mountain in December 2022, following a dispute with the West Sumatra department of Balai Konservasi Sumber Daya Alam (BKSDA), Indonesia’s environmental conservation company, which took over the administration of Mount Marapi, and the nationwide park through which it sits, in July 2022.
In Ajo’s telling, the dispute stemmed from an “ambiguous and misleading” announcement that BKSDA put out in regards to the security of the mountain on the finish of 2022.
In response to the announcement, Mount Marapi was to be closed to the general public from December 30, 2022 to January 2, 2023 attributable to “elevated volcanic exercise since December 25”.
“It was duping the general public, as a result of they opened entry to the volcano once more on January 3. How did they know when the volcanic exercise was going to lower?” Ajo mentioned.
‘Mountain of fireplace’
Referred to as “Mountain of Fireplace” in Indonesian, Marapi – to not be confused with Mount Merapi in Central Java and the identically named Mount Merapi in East Java – has an extended and violent historical past, with its first recorded eruption courting again to 1830.
In 1979, the mountain erupted once more, killing 60 folks, and one individual died following an eruption in 1996.
In 2011, the alert stage for the volcano, which sits at 2,885 metres (9,465.2 toes) above sea stage, was raised from stage one to stage two, as a part of a four-tier alert system used to categorise volcanic exercise in Indonesia.
Catastrophe company Pusat Vulkanologi dan Mitigasi Bencana Geologi (PVMBG) additionally banned folks from trekking inside three kilometres of the crater amid fears of additional eruptions, though the company itself had no authority to implement the ban, which was on the discretion of the native authorities in West Sumatra.
Earlier than July 2022, Marapi had been managed by locals who organised treks on the height, offered tickets and banned climbers from venturing onto the mountain after they deemed it unsafe.
After BKSDA took over, the company streamlined and up to date the earlier administration system, launching a brand new on-line reserving system for hikers that restricted the variety of guests to a most of 150 folks per day, and charging $0.32 for admission on weekdays and $0.48 on weekends.
Ajo mentioned that BKDSA’s administration of Marapi was “haphazard”.
“There was plenty of hypothesis circulating at the moment [of the change of management] that BKSDA didn’t have the flexibility, ability, readiness or human sources workers who have been competent in mountain administration,” he mentioned.
“Ranger groups, administration groups and cell groups are all wanted to make sure security. That they had none of these.”
Following the December eruption, BKSDA is now formally below investigation by West Sumatran authorities to find out whether or not there was any negligence concerned within the catastrophe.
Ajo is just not alone amongst native sources who consider that lack of life on the mountain was an accident ready to occur.
“It was not simply negligence, there was truly a component of intention right here,” Wengki Purwanto, the director of the West Sumatra department of the Indonesian Discussion board for Atmosphere non-profit organisation, instructed Al Jazeera.
“Formally, the federal government opened the mountain for tourism and there have been tariffs set. This was clearly a coverage that ignored attainable catastrophe points. The federal government has full knowledge on the standing of volcanoes, however it isn’t used as a reference for tourism administration primarily based on catastrophe mitigation,” he mentioned.
“The federal government can not threat lives for financial causes.”
He mentioned there ought to have been officers situated at Marapi to make sure the security and safety of climbers, and officers stationed at prohibited places on the mountain, such because the three-kilometre “crimson zone”.
In response to Ajo, when BKSDA took over administration of the world, there have been quite a few customary working procedures and guidelines, together with a stipulation that solely native guides have been allowed to take guests to the mountain.
As an alternative, native guides who complained about issues of safety have been not allowed to guide excursions, Ajo mentioned, and guides from outdoors the world have been introduced in as an alternative, regardless of not being acquainted with the native terrain and the volatility of the mountain.
An official investigation into the allegations is constant. Authorities haven’t named anybody from BKSDA as a suspect in a possible case of negligence, which carries a most penalty of 5 years in jail below Indonesian legislation.
In an announcement supplied to Al Jazeera relating to allegations of negligence and questions in regards to the mountain being opened to the general public in January 2023 regardless of warnings from native guides, a spokesperson for BKSDA denied any wrongdoing.
“The accusations of negligence are the opinion of events who solely witnessed a fraction of the incident on December 3,” it mentioned. “The Marapi administration coverage referred to laws and knowledge that have been despatched to our establishment by the federal government.”
“Those that understand how the administration of Marapi labored is not going to decide.”