Jamie Golombek: This is what occurred in a latest case the place a taxpayer was compelled to repay a few of his GIS
Opinions and suggestions are unbiased and merchandise are independently chosen. Postmedia might earn an affiliate fee from purchases made by hyperlinks on this web page.
Article content material
We pay tax not solely on our Canadian-source employment, enterprise or funding revenue, however on our whole worldwide revenue, together with overseas revenue, equivalent to a foreign pension, which should first be transformed to Canadian {dollars} earlier than it’s reported on our returns yearly.
The result’s that Canadian tax is payable on this overseas revenue, which can also be included in your “annual web world revenue” used to find out eligibility for sure authorities income-tested advantages, such because the Assured Earnings Complement (GIS) and Old Age Security (OAS).
Commercial 2
Article content material
Article content material
A latest Tax Courtroom case concerned a taxpayer who was compelled to repay a few of his GIS because of his overseas pension revenue. The taxpayer filed an attraction with the Social Safety Tribunal after the Employment and Social Growth Canada (ESDC) decided he had been “overpaid” GIS due to “an incorrect calculation of his revenue.”
As with different OAS-type appeals, the court docket’s jurisdiction is restricted to figuring out whether or not the taxpayer’s revenue was accurately calculated. On this case, the query earlier than the court docket was whether or not the taxpayer’s revenue for the interval of July 2014 to June 2018 was correctly decided for the aim of his GIS entitlement.
The taxpayer is each a Romanian and Canadian citizen who collects pension revenue in each nations. He receives the GIS and OAS. From July 2014 by June 2018, nonetheless, ESDC decided he had been overpaid $2,044 in GIS revenue.
GIS eligibility relies on revenue and is out there to low-income OAS pensioners. For instance, within the fourth quarter of 2023, a single senior whose annual revenue is beneath $21,456 receives as much as $1,057 of GIS monthly. GIS advantages are typically lowered by 50 cents for each greenback of revenue, apart from OAS and GIS.
Article content material
Commercial 3
Article content material
Within the present case, the dispute wasn’t whether or not the taxpayer’s Romanian pension was taxable, however whether or not he might deduct the banking and cost-of-currency-exchange charges he paid to repatriate his Romanian pension to Canada as a part of this calculation. The taxpayer additionally felt ESDC incorrectly transformed his pension revenue to Canadian {dollars}.
The decide reviewed the legislation, which is obvious: for GIS functions, a taxpayer’s web revenue is calculated based on the Earnings Tax Act, which incorporates worldwide revenue and any overseas pension revenue. The decide stated the provisions of the Previous Age Safety Act merely don’t present for a deduction of banking charges or currency-exchange prices when calculating web revenue for GIS functions, and, because of this, was unable to just accept the taxpayer’s argument that his revenue must be lowered by these quantities for GIS functions.
The taxpayer then argued ESDC incorrectly utilized the overseas alternate fee to transform his Romanian pension funds from Romanian leu to Canadian {dollars}. However the decide might discover no foundation for this argument. Citing the Canada Income Company’s Federal Earnings Tax and Profit Information — within the part entitled Report overseas revenue and different overseas quantities — taxpayers are instructed to make use of the Bank of Canada exchange rate in impact on the day overseas revenue is acquired to transform the quantities to Canadian {dollars}.
Commercial 4
Article content material
This appears to be what ESDC did, so the decide concluded the overseas alternate calculation was executed appropriately. Consequently, the taxpayer misplaced his attraction and was compelled to repay a part of his GIS.
It must be famous that for overseas revenue, the CRA can even typically settle for a fee for a selected day from one other supply if it meets all the next situations: it’s extensively accessible, verifiable, printed by an unbiased supplier on an ongoing foundation, acknowledged by the market, utilized in accordance with well-accepted enterprise ideas, used to organize monetary statements (if relevant) and used often from 12 months to 12 months. Different sources the CRA will typically settle for embody charges from Bloomberg LP, Thomson Reuters Corp. and Oanda Corp.
In sure circumstances, nonetheless, the CRA does allow a median fee for use to transform overseas foreign money quantities to Canadian {dollars} for tax functions. That is notably handy if a overseas quantity is paid to you evenly all year long.
For instance, when you acquired dividends from america all through 2023, you’ll be able to apply the common annual Canada/U.S. overseas alternate fee to the overall U.S. greenback dividends acquired, somewhat than searching down the person fee on every particular dividend fee date.
Commercial 5
Article content material
However simply because the common annual alternate fee is handy doesn’t imply it’s all the time one of the best outcome. In a 2007 technical interpretation letter, the CRA was requested whether or not a taxpayer was required to make use of the Financial institution of Canada’s annual common alternate fee to transform pension and funding revenue to Canadian {dollars}. The taxpayer wished to know if she might ignore the common annual fee for the 12 months and use the precise alternate charges she acquired from her financial institution when she deposited her overseas pension and funding revenue into her Canadian checking account.
The CRA responded that there was nothing within the Earnings Tax Act or the company’s printed materials that requires a taxpayer to make use of the Financial institution of Canada’s annual common alternate fee to transform pension or funding revenue to Canadian {dollars}, since you’re technically supposed to make use of the speed on the date the revenue was acquired.
You’re additionally required to make use of the precise overseas alternate fee that was in impact on the day of the transaction relating to the calculation of a acquire (or loss) on the sale of overseas property, equivalent to U.S.-denominated shares, bonds or overseas actual property.
Commercial 6
Article content material
Associated Tales
In different phrases, to correctly report a acquire (or loss) on a overseas property, you’d convert the proceeds to Canadian {dollars} utilizing the alternate fee on the date of sale, and evaluate that to the adjusted value base (ACB) or tax value of the property utilizing the overseas alternate fee on the date of buy of the property.
Jamie Golombek, FCPA, FCA, CFP, CLU, TEP, is the managing director, Tax & Property Planning with CIBC Personal Wealth in Toronto. Jamie.Golombek@cibc.com.
If you happen to appreciated this story, join extra within the FP Investor e-newsletter.
Article content material